Share this to:

Support & Insight for the Autumn of Life

USA Bans Nursing Home Arbitrators

PEOPLE WITH DEMENTIA cannot easily protect themselves. Nursing homes have long dodged accountability for dementia patients by making new residents sign a “pre-dispute arbitration agreement“. Thanks to Medicare and Medicaid, that tactic has finally come to a halt.

San Francisco – An outright ban on the use of pre-dispute binding arbitration agreements highlights the most significant re-write of federal nursing home regulations in 25 years.

Since the time that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) posted their final rule for revising the requirements that nursing homes must meet to receive Medicare and Medicaid funding, America has been a far friendlier place for nursing home residents.

Great Impact

The rule is 713 pages long and affects virtually every aspect of the lives of nursing home residents but one sentence on page 689 will likely have the greatest impact:

A facility must not enter into a pre-dispute agreement for binding arbitration with any resident or resident’s representative.

Calling pre-dispute arbitration agreements “unconscionable” by their very nature, CMS has protected nursing home residents from signing away their rights to file lawsuits when they are subjected to abuse or neglect or have their rights violated. Arbitration agreements are used by nearly all nursing homes to ensure residents have limited options when they are harmed or need justice.

Since CMS and state survey agencies have ditched strong regulatory enforcement in favor of a collaborative, education-oriented approach, private lawsuits are critical for improving nursing home care. Until CMS’s rule, nursing homes had used arbitration agreements to insulate themselves from accountability.

The pre-dispute arbitration agreement ban has been in effect for almost 2 years now. Agreements signed prior to that date are unaffected by the rule. The rule does not apply to assisted living facilities, despite the fact that pre-dispute arbitration agreements are similarly unconscionable to their residents.

Basic Constitutional Rights

Pat McGinnis, CANHR’s Executive Director, stated “This is a long-overdue rule. No citizen should be required to surrender basic constitutional rights and civil protections to secure a bed in a nursing home as a condition for adequate care.  We are glad that CMS has finally recognized this.”

Aside from the ban on pre-dispute arbitration agreements, the rule includes many provisions that could hurt nursing home residents, including no minimum staffing requirement and no new limitations on the use of chemical restraints on residents.

About CANHR: California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (CANHR), is a statewide nonprofit advocacy organization dedicated to improving the choices, care and quality of life for California’s long term care consumers. Through direct advocacy, community education, legislation and litigation it has been CANHR’s goal to educate and support long term care consumers and advocates regarding the rights and remedies under the law, and to create a united voice for long term care reform and humane alternatives to institutionalization.

California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (CANHR) 
650 Harrison Street, 2nd Floor, San Francisco, CA 94107 

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
October 7, 2016 2:07 pm

I am thrilled to read this!
Be aware of ALL facilities your loved one enters. Even the "best" will give you cause to question their ethics, and skills. And, actually, you may be smart to test the facility before admitting someone for an extended time. I speak from experience! I was forced to place my husband, who has Alzheimer's in a facility that was labeled the best where we live for a short time. I had to go out of state, and luckily my daughter was able to stop in to see him there. She was shocked. He was not in the room assigned to him. There were no aids to help him to his room, or help feed him. He did not receive this medication. And, he fell out of bed the first night. His room was locked with NO light turned on??? And, they called this a Memory Health Care Unit??? It was an expensive baby sitting facility! No one cared that these patients could not fend for themselves! On the second day, he was taken home and a home health care agency was called in. Visiting Angels! And they were…..Our hands were tied to legally go further. The health department was notified, but nothing ever came of it. BE AWARE!! They are making fortunes, and at your loved ones expense. Dont take their word for anything…. you have every right to come and go to check on them…. and I recommend you do. God bless you and your loved one.

April 6, 2017 8:02 pm

This ruling is good for the future but not retroactive for those already in facilities of this type. It is a step but not nearly broad enough as many who are in assisted living are actually dementia sufferers. As well the last statement offers little or no comfort for what ails the system of caregiver training and adequate staffing. Chemical restraint is rampant and unconscionable. Visit facilities for memory care and it is eye opening. The system is extremely poor in this country and we would do well to follow the nurturing lead of some other countries who are outdoing us for care when it concerns memory cary.

September 3, 2022 3:19 pm

Keep them home

B. Berger

B. Berger

Visit Our Pages On:


This site was inspired by my Mom’s autoimmune dementia.

It is a place where we separate out the wheat from the chaffe, the important articles & videos from each week’s river of news. With a new post on Alzheimer’s or dementia appearing on the internet every 7 minutes, the site’s focus on the best information has been a help to many over the past 15 years. Thanks to our many subscribers for your supportive feedback.

The site is dedicated to all those preserving the dignity of the community of people living with dementia.

Peter Berger, Editor


Alzheimer's Mealtime: Eat Together to Eat Well
With dementia, it’s not just what you eat – it’s also how and where!
A Tornado and Alzheimer's
A tornado has left 40 Alzheimer's patients on the move. See how dementia is especially vulnerable to natural disaster...
Dad Doesn't Remember Daughter, but Feels Love
Scott doesn't remember his daughter or his wife, but he does remember the love they share. Watch how his daughter Bai...


Amazon Books
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
News to Get at the Truth

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

Enjoy thought-provoking videos & articles
News to Get at the Truth

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter